An AI-generated website can be a solid starting point but it should never go live exactly as the tool spits it out. Before you publish, check four things: does it actually look like your brand, does the copy mean something specific, does every page guide visitors toward hiring you, and does it stand out from every other AI-built site out there.
Read or listen to this episode
Or listen on Spotify | Apple | iHeartRadio
Okay, real talk. “Why would I hire a web designer when I can just ask Claude to build my website?” I get asked this all the time. (Right up there with “Aren’t you scared AI is going to take your job?”)
And honestly? It’s a fair question. Tools like Claude, ChatGPT, and Lovable can do more every single month. You drop in your business info, describe what you want, and boom, a fully built website appears. We are living in the future, straight up. When you’re early in business and watching every dollar, I completely understand the appeal of an AI-generated website.
But here’s what I want you to think about before you hit publish: the number one goal of your website is to make it stupidly easy for someone to hire you. That takes a lot of strategic decisions. So let’s look at what an AI-generated website gets right, where it falls short, and exactly what to check before yours goes live.
Why does every AI-generated website look the same?
AI website builders pull from the same patterns, so most AI-generated websites end up with similar layouts, the same handful of fonts, matching icon styles, and even identical phrasing. Once you’ve seen a few, you can spot one in seconds. And you don’t have to be a designer to notice. Your potential clients are clocking it too.
Here’s why that matters. Your website is a reflection of your entire brand. When it looks like everyone else’s, it reads as generic, and people assume that carries over to your work.
You care so deeply about the details in what you deliver to clients. I know you do. But if someone is meeting you for the first time, or checking you out after a referral, and they land on a templated AI-generated website, they may walk away feeling a little less sure about you. They won’t consciously think, “She didn’t pay attention to the details.” They’ll just feel it. And that quiet doubt erodes trust.
It’s the same thing that happens with AI slop on LinkedIn. You see a post that was clearly copied straight from ChatGPT, and what do you do? You scroll right past. It’s not interesting, and it doesn’t show you the human behind it. People are getting more and more attuned to AI patterns everywhere, and websites are no exception.
To be fair, I’ve seen exceptions. Developers and people with design, messaging, or user psychology backgrounds can take an AI-generated website as a starting point and shape it into something truly distinct. The key word there is starting point.
Check #1: Does your AI-generated website actually feel like your brand?
Start with the most important question: does this feel like your business? Look at your AI-generated website and ask:
- Does it show the unique magic your brand brings to the table?
- Does it capture what you do and how you do it differently?
- Are the fonts, images, and overall design how you want people to experience your company?
- Does it look like something you’ve seen a million times before?
If you have a visual brand, make sure it comes through clearly and consistently on every page.
A word of warning about colors. You’ve probably heard that AI tools can “hallucinate,” meaning they confidently make things up, like facts or research papers that don’t exist. In my experience, Claude hallucinates colors in particular. It has tried to change my brand colors so many times, even after I’ve handed it the exact hex codes. So double check that your AI-generated website is actually using your real brand colors and fonts.
Check #2: Does your AI-generated copy actually mean something?
Copy is probably the most important piece of any website. Design matters a ton, but your words are what tell people what you do. And the biggest problem with AI-generated website copy isn’t em dashes or buzzwords. It’s that AI writes copy that sounds nice and means literally nothing.
Take a headline like “Elevate your business with innovative, tailored solutions.” Okay… what does that mean? I can tell it’s supposed to be a good thing. But I have no idea if you do bookkeeping, web design, or business coaching. I don’t know what problem you solve or how you solve it differently.
Or “Empowering you to unlock your full potential.” My full potential in what? What are we actually working on together?
So here’s the one blanket rule I’ll give you: never, ever publish AI-generated copy without editing it. Not just deleting a few em dashes. Actually read every line and ask:
- Does this sentence actually mean something?
- Could I explain it in plain language?
- Does it tell the reader something useful about my work and my approach?
- Does it help them understand exactly what they can come to me for?
What clear website copy looks like
Let’s say you’re a business coach who works with solo service providers struggling to decide what to offer, how to price it, and what to focus on next. You could simply say:
“I help solo service providers decide what to offer, what to charge, and what to prioritize next.”
Could it be punchier? Sure. But the second someone reads it, they know exactly what you do and whether it’s relevant to them. If they’re stuck on those decisions, they have a reason to keep reading.
Clear copy removes a barrier for your audience. Vague copy makes them work hard to figure out what you do, why they’re there, and what to do next. Your people are busy. Make them work too hard and you’ll lose them.
Check #3: Does your AI-generated website lead people to hire you?
A good website isn’t just a collection of pages. It’s a user journey: how someone moves through your site and what helps them take the next step. Most AI-generated websites skip this strategy entirely.
When I plan a website for a client, I think about the psychology of the person landing on it. What challenge are they facing? What are they hoping to find? What’s keeping them up at night? And am I showing them, clearly and immediately, why and how to take the next step?
Every page needs a clear purpose
This might make me the minority among web designers, but after 16+ years in this space, I don’t believe more content is automatically better. Yes, more pages can mean more for Google and AI search tools to crawl, with some caveats. But content for the sake of content doesn’t make sense. Every page should answer three questions:
- Why does this page exist?
- What is it leading to?
- What action is it driving someone toward?
Back to our business coach. Her end goal is getting hired, but someone who just found her probably isn’t buying a $2,000 package on day one. She needs to build trust first. So maybe she offers a freebie, like a free 30-minute session, a downloadable framework, or an email series. Once that freebie is defined, most pages on her site have one job: lead visitors to sign up for it.
(That’s an example, not a prescription. You may not need a freebie at all.) The real takeaway: every page needs a clear purpose and should lead to an action that actually makes sense.
What if you don’t have the budget for a web designer?
Maybe you’re thinking, “Okay Rachel, this all sounds great in theory, but I’m just getting started and I don’t have the budget.” That is so fair, and I want to sit with it for a second.
People come to me all the time embarrassed that they DIY’d their website, and now, embarrassed that they used Claude to build it. My response? Don’t be. You started a business. You are fully responsible for everything, and that is seriously badass. Then you figured out how to build a website when that’s probably not your zone of genius. Be proud of that.
Ideally, branding and a website are part of your startup costs. But if they can’t be right now, use an AI-generated website and run it through the checklist below.
It’s not all or nothing
A lot of founders think the only options are a $10,000 custom website or 100% DIY. There’s a lot of room in between:
- Build your AI-generated website, then have a professional audit it and tell you what to improve
- Hire a pro to clean up and polish what AI created
- Outsource specific pieces, like copy or the user journey, and handle the rest yourself
You’re doing the best with what you have. When the time is right, bring in a professional.
The same rules apply to AI-generated flyers
Can we talk about AI flyers for a minute? They’re everywhere: my feed, newspapers, all over the place. And they have the exact same problems as an AI-generated website.
I showed my husband (who is basically never on social media) three AI flyers that popped up back to back on Instagram. One was a yoga studio, one was a martial arts school, and one wasn’t even in English. Different colors, different photos. His reaction? “Oh, they’re all the exact same flyer.”
Here’s what to fix:
- Too much information. AI flyers cram in buzzwords, graphics, and about 17 different calls to action. Keep only the essential info and one clear next step.
- Over the top graphics. You don’t need confetti, arrows, sparkles, starbursts, badges, and decorative borders. Remember the old rule: take off one accessory before you walk out the door. Less is more.
- Generic fonts. Use your actual brand fonts, or at least something legible that doesn’t match everyone else’s flyer.
- AI-generated photos of you. Swap them for a real photo. Lean into real, human elements wherever you can.
Your AI-generated website checklist
Before your AI-generated website goes live, run it through these questions:
- Does it look different from every other AI-built website out there?
- Does it actually capture my brand, including my real colors and fonts?
- Does every line of copy mean something specific, or is it generic fluff?
- Have I edited all the AI-generated copy myself?
- Does each page have a clear purpose?
- Does the site guide visitors through a journey that leads them to work with me?
Frequently asked questions about AI-generated websites
Is it okay to use an AI-generated website for my business?
Yes, especially when you’re just starting out and budget is tight. Treat it as a first draft, not a finished product. Edit the copy, confirm your branding, and map out a clear user journey before you publish.
How can people tell a website is AI-generated?
AI-generated websites tend to share the same layouts, fonts, icons, and vague phrasing like “innovative, tailored solutions.” Most visitors can’t name exactly what tipped them off, but they recognize the pattern instantly.
What’s the biggest mistake people make with AI-generated websites?
Publishing AI-generated copy without editing it. AI often writes copy that sounds polished but doesn’t explain what you do, who you help, or why someone should choose you.
Should I hire a web designer or use AI to build my website?
It doesn’t have to be one or the other. You can build an AI-generated website yourself and then hire a professional to audit it, clean it up, or handle specific pieces. When you’re able to, investing in professional branding and web design pays off in trust and conversions.
The bottom line
If an AI-generated website is what your budget allows right now, that’s totally okay. Just don’t publish it as is. Make sure it’s distinct, captures your brand, uses copy that means something, and leads visitors on a clear path to working with you.
And when you’re ready to invest, know this: clients regularly tell me they hired me because my brand stood out and they knew right away what I stand for and how I’m different. Your brand and website really do make that difference.
Want to know how your website stacks up? Take my free Website Scorecard to see what’s working, what’s working against you, and the next steps to fix it.

